You Are Here: Home » Real Estate » Senate Bill Might Evict Affordable Housing Goals

Senate Bill Might Evict Affordable Housing Goals

Charlene Crowell

Charlene Crowell

By Charlene Crowell

In an unconventional move, legislation designed to reshape the nation’s $10 trillion housing finance market was released on Sunday, March 16. Since then, reactions to proposed broad changes have ranged from strong support to ‘wait-and-see, and outright opposition.

According to the bill’s authors, Senators Tim Johnson, Chair of Senate Banking Committee and Mike Crapo, the committee’s Ranking Member, the rare weekend release was the result of months of effort to accommodate varied input to secure bipartisan support and move the proposal forward in time for a full Senate vote by November.

In a news release, Johnson said, “This proposal includes an explicit guarantee in order to add stability to the economy, keep costs reasonable for borrowers and renters, and ensure fair access to the secondary market for all lenders.”

Crapo said, “There is broad support to fix our flawed housing system, and today’s actions are a strong step toward ending the status quo.”

But just how much support there is for the 442-page legislation really depends on who is speaking.

“Housing finance reform was too important to rush a committee deal on, and in my view, it’s also too important to rush a markup on,” said Senator Elizabeth Warren, also a member of the Senate Banking Committee. “We should have a full, open discussion before we decide to set out on a new path, and that means members of the Banking Committee should have real time to dig in and consult with people before a markup.”

While the Senate Banking Committee deliberates on the proposed legislation, organizations that researched the housing crisis and others representing consumers affected by it are speaking up.

In a recent radio interview, Mike Calhoun, president of the Center for Responsible Lending (CRL) said, “It’s a radical surgery proposal; it’s somewhere between a complete tear-down and an extreme gut rehab. The question is does that get us to a better place? And middle and moderate income families might be less served with this approach. The new model could make it harder and more expensive for a lot of people to get mortgages.”

CRL research shows that the average family would need 14 years to save enough money for a 5 percent down payment. For Black families, the number of required years would double to 28 for the same 5 percent and 17 years of saving for the average Latino family.

Further, home down payment savings do not take into account closing costs, which typically are an added 3 percent of the cost of the mortgage or mortgage insurance that is required for homes purchased with less than a 20 percent down payment. In CRL’s view, there is no wisdom in requiring these homeownership delays when so many families have successfully paid mortgages made with low down payments such as FHA loans.

Charlene Crowell is a communications manager with the Center for Responsible Lending. She can be reached at

Share This Story!

    About The Author

    Number of Entries : 10098
    Scroll to top